BRAVA vs. Asphalt vs. Metal: Choosing the Right Roof for Your Northern Virginia Home
Asphalt is the best value, metal is built for maximum lifespan, and BRAVA gives you the look of slate, shake or tile without the weight. Here's how to choose.

In this article
For most Northern Virginia homes, architectural asphalt shingles are the best value, metal roofing gives you the longest low-maintenance life, and BRAVA composite gives you the high-end look of slate, cedar shake or tile with a roughly 50-year outlook and far less weight than the real thing. The right choice comes down to three things: your budget, how long you plan to stay in the home, and the look you want. This guide compares all three side by side so you can narrow it down before you talk to a roofer.
Blue Tower installs all three. We're an Owens Corning Preferred Contractor, a GAF Certified Installer and a BRAVA Certified Installer, so we don't have a reason to push one material over another. We'd rather you end up with the roof that fits your home.
The quick comparison
| Asphalt shingles | Metal roofing | BRAVA composite | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Look | Classic, wide color range | Clean, modern lines | Authentic slate, shake or tile |
| Typical lifespan | Shortest of the three | Long | About 50-year outlook |
| Upfront cost | Lowest | Higher | Highest |
| Weight | Light | Very light | Light (far lighter than real slate or tile) |
| Maintenance | Low | Very low | Very low |
| Storm toughness | Good; impact-rated lines available | Very good | Strong; check the impact rating of the line |
| Best for | Most homes and budgets | Long-term owners who want durability | Standout curb appeal and long-term value |
Lifespans depend on the product line, the attic ventilation underneath, and how well the roof is installed. Manufacturer warranties vary by product, so ask about the specific line you're considering.
Asphalt shingles: the reliable standard
Asphalt shingles cover most homes in Northern Virginia, and for good reason. Modern architectural (dimensional) shingles are thicker than the old flat three-tab style, look better, and hold up better in wind.
Why homeowners choose asphalt
- The best value. Asphalt has the lowest upfront cost of the three, so it's the most budget-friendly way to get a quality new roof.
- A huge range of styles and colors. It's easy to match your siding, trim and neighborhood.
- Easy to repair. Individual shingles can be replaced after storm damage.
- Proven in our climate. It handles Northern Virginia's hot summers, cold snaps and storms well when it's installed with good ventilation and proper flashing.
The trade-offs
- The shortest lifespan of the three. Three-tab shingles here often wear out around 15–20 years; architectural shingles run longer. Heat, poor attic ventilation and storm damage all shorten the clock.
- More vulnerable to hail and wind than metal or a premium composite, although impact-rated shingle lines are available.
Who it's best for
Homeowners who want a great-looking, long-lasting roof at a sensible price, and anyone who may sell in the next 10–15 years. Our go-to is Owens Corning architectural shingles, with GAF shingles also available — we're a GAF Certified Installer.

Metal roofing: built for the long haul
Metal roofing, especially standing seam, has become a popular choice for homeowners who want to install a roof once and not think about it again for a very long time.
Why homeowners choose metal
- Long life. A well-installed metal roof can last decades longer than asphalt.
- Very low maintenance. No granules to lose, no shingles to blow off.
- Sheds water and snow well. Smooth panels shed rain fast and let snow slide off.
- A clean, modern look that suits farmhouse, contemporary and many traditional homes.
- Lightweight, so it puts little load on the structure.
The trade-offs
- Higher upfront cost than asphalt.
- The look isn't for every home or neighborhood. Some HOAs have rules about roofing materials, so check yours first.
- Repairs take specialized work, and dents from large hail are possible depending on the panel.
Who it's best for
Long-term owners who want maximum durability and low upkeep, and homes where the modern look fits. It's also a smart choice for porches, additions and outbuildings.
BRAVA composite: the luxury look without the weight
BRAVA is a premium synthetic roofing system that recreates the look of natural slate, cedar shake and Spanish tile using engineered composite materials. It's for homeowners who want a roof that turns heads, without the cracking, rotting or crushing weight of the natural materials.
Why homeowners choose BRAVA
- The look you actually want. Authentic slate, shake and tile profiles in a wide range of colors, including custom blends.
- About a 50-year outlook, backed by a strong manufacturer warranty. Ask us for the current warranty details on the line you choose.
- Lightweight. Real slate and tile often need structural reinforcement. BRAVA usually doesn't.
- Low maintenance. No rot, no insects, no splitting shakes or cracked slate.
- Built tough. BRAVA lists Class 4 impact resistance and a Class A fire rating for its systems. Confirm the current specs for the profile you pick.
The trade-offs
- The highest upfront cost of the three.
- It has to be installed by a certified installer to perform as designed and keep the warranty valid. Most local roofers aren't certified.
Who it's best for
Homeowners who plan to stay in the home for the long term, want standout curb appeal, or own a home where slate, shake or tile is the right architectural fit. Learn more about BRAVA roofing.

How to choose: five questions to ask yourself
1. How long will you stay in the home?
If you might sell in the next decade, a quality asphalt roof is usually the smartest spend. If this is your long-term home, metal or BRAVA can mean you never replace the roof again, and the higher upfront cost is spread over many more years.
2. What's your budget, really?
Asphalt costs least upfront. Metal and BRAVA cost more but last longer. Look at the cost per year of service life, not just the day-one price. Financing can also make a longer-lasting roof more realistic.
3. What look fits your home and neighborhood?
A brick colonial, a modern farmhouse and a historic stone house each look best with something different. If you're in an HOA, check what's allowed before you fall in love with a material.
4. How much storm exposure does your home get?
Northern Virginia gets strong summer storms, wind and occasional hail. Exposed lots, big nearby trees and hilltop homes take more of a beating. Impact-rated asphalt, metal and BRAVA all add storm resilience.
5. Who's installing it?
This matters more than the material. A premium roof installed badly fails early, and a standard roof installed well can outlast expectations. Manufacturer warranties depend on installation to spec, which is why certification matters. Compare all the options on our roofing materials page.
What about insurance claims?
If your roof is being replaced through an insurance claim, the policy usually pays for a comparable roof to the one you had. Upgrading to metal or BRAVA is often possible: you typically pay the difference. Check your policy and ask your adjuster how upgrades are handled. Blue Tower helps homeowners through roof insurance claims from inspection to installation.
Get an honest recommendation
The best way to decide is to have someone look at your actual roof, attic and home, then walk you through the options with real numbers. Blue Tower's inspections and consultations are free, and we'll tell you honestly which material makes sense, even if it's the least expensive one.
Schedule a free roof inspection or call 571-228-6974. Ready to plan a new roof? Start with our roof replacement page.
Frequently asked questions
Which roofing material lasts the longest?
Metal and BRAVA composite last the longest of the three. BRAVA has about a 50-year outlook, and a well-installed metal roof can last for decades. Quality asphalt shingles have the shortest life but the lowest upfront cost.
Is BRAVA worth the extra cost?
It is for homeowners who plan to stay long-term and want the look of slate, shake or tile. You get a premium appearance and a very long service life without the weight or upkeep of natural materials. If you may sell soon, asphalt is usually the better spend.
Is a metal roof noisy in the rain?
Usually not noticeably. Over solid roof decking with underlayment and an insulated attic, rain on a metal roof typically sounds much like rain on any other roof.
Can I put a heavy roof like slate on any house?
Not always. Natural slate and tile are heavy and may need structural reinforcement. BRAVA composite looks like slate or tile but weighs far less, so it usually doesn't.
Do you install all three types?
Yes. Blue Tower installs Owens Corning and GAF asphalt shingles, metal roofing and BRAVA composite roofing. We're a BRAVA Certified Installer and an Owens Corning Preferred Contractor.
How do I know which roof is right for my home?
Start with a free inspection and consultation. We'll look at your roof, attic and home, ask how long you plan to stay, and give you an honest recommendation. Schedule a free roof inspection.
Keep reading
Roof Replacement & Installation
Roof Replacement Cost in Northern Virginia: What Homeowners Should Expect
Shield your investment.
Protect your home for the long haul.
Roofing, Siding, Gutters, and Peace of Mind.


